I would like to request a more transparent and more flexible SQM option inside IntelliQoS.
I understand that IntelliQoS already provides application classification, traffic prioritization and CAKE-based SQM/AQM behavior.
However, some users may prefer an OpenWrt like CAKE-only SQM mode that focuses mainly on queue control, fairness and bufferbloat reduction, without depending on application classification or an NFQ/classification-based traffic path.
My request is not to remove IntelliQoS. Instead, please consider adding an optional mode such as:
IntelliQoS automatic mode;
IntelliQoS with application prioritization;
CAKE-only SQM mode.
The CAKE-only mode would be useful for users who want predictable latency control even when traffic is encrypted, unknown, mixed, VPN-based, or not classified correctly. In many real home networks, perfect application recognition is difficult.
It would also be useful to document or expose which CAKE/SQM mechanisms are active, such as:
device/host fairness;
flow fairness;
DiffServ behavior, including modes similar to besteffort, diffserv3 or diffserv4;
NAT awareness;
ACK filtering;
WAN overhead compensation for PPPoE, VLAN, DSL, cable and Ethernet;
download-side SQM using ingress shaping / IFB-like behavior;
whether SQM is active on upload, download or both.
The main practical benefit would be a choice between two approaches:
IntelliQoS mode: application-aware prioritization and automatic classification.
CAKE-only SQM mode: advanced, more deterministic queue management focused on fairness and stable loaded latency.
This would make KeeneticOS more attractive to advanced users who currently prefer OpenWrt SQM-CAKE for predictable bufferbloat control, host fairness and transparent CAKE behavior.
You can post now and register later.
If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.
Question
Woolf
Hello Keenetic team,
I would like to request a more transparent and more flexible SQM option inside IntelliQoS.
I understand that IntelliQoS already provides application classification, traffic prioritization and CAKE-based SQM/AQM behavior.
However, some users may prefer an OpenWrt like CAKE-only SQM mode that focuses mainly on queue control, fairness and bufferbloat reduction, without depending on application classification or an NFQ/classification-based traffic path.
My request is not to remove IntelliQoS. Instead, please consider adding an optional mode such as:
The CAKE-only mode would be useful for users who want predictable latency control even when traffic is encrypted, unknown, mixed, VPN-based, or not classified correctly. In many real home networks, perfect application recognition is difficult.
It would also be useful to document or expose which CAKE/SQM mechanisms are active, such as:
The main practical benefit would be a choice between two approaches:
This would make KeeneticOS more attractive to advanced users who currently prefer OpenWrt SQM-CAKE for predictable bufferbloat control, host fairness and transparent CAKE behavior.
Thank you for considering this request.
Edited by Woolf0 answers to this question
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.